Unlocked Mobiles and Your Choice

Nokia Lumia 900 and iPhone 5 at Caribou Coffee
This past weekend, the USA mobile and technology community experienced something that doesn’t come around so often – the removable of rights, or as I’d argue, the perceived ability to make a choice towards what you can do with mobiles.

The short end of things is that starting Saturday, any mobile devices that you purchase cannot be unlocked unless the terms of the original sold contact are completed. Or, to quote the CTIA blog:

…That’s all that is happening here: consumers who pay the full price for a phone can take that phone to the carrier (or carriers) of their choice. However, if a carrier subsidized the price of the phone in exchange for the consumer’s agreement to use the phone on that carrier’s network, the consumer can only transfer the phone to a new carrier once the terms of the contract (or the carrier’s unlocking policy) have been satisfied…

Now, to clear up the confusion… because its gotten really long in the mouths of many folks talking about it.

When you purchase a mobile from your carrier, and sign a contract to do so, you are generally paying only a portion of the complete cost of the mobile device. The rest of the cost is spread out over the life of the contract. Yes, you don’t own the mobile when you purchase it on a contract, you lease it.

You have a choice to purchase a mobile outside of this contract-lease method. In this case, you would purchase the mobile, usually from the manufacturer, or another retailer. These mobiles are much more expensive – because the carrier is not subsidizing part of the cost of the device for you. And then after purchasing the device, you will have to find a plan (whether that’s pre or post-paid) that works with your mobile device. Now, you can choose to get on a contract, but generally, and I’m speaking only of USA carriers since this law is only in effect here, you can’t negotiate a contract. Its only with the carrier T-Mobile that you have the case where if you come with your own device that the cost for a contract plan is less than if you purchase both the device and contract from them.

The other aspect of this law happens to take effect when you decide that you want to sell a device. You see, many folks make the choice to sell their device to another company (like Amazon, Gazelle, etc.) before the contract is up, so that they can recoup some funds and then get something new. Thing is, the person purchasing the device would be breaking the law to unlock it so that they can use it. Ouch right? Well, it is for folks that like to purchase and release mobiles often. Essentially, these people would need to buy-out their contracts, then have the device unlocked by the carrier, then sell the device.

Almost makes it crazy to think of purchasing a mobile on contract now doesn’t it?

Look, I get it that it makes it a lot more difficult for some of you who are under a social and economic obligation to have the (near-)latest mobile device to have one. Getting an unlocked device from your carrier, and even opting into extending your contract to do so remains an option, just more expensive to pursue.

If you are someone who travels beyond the shores of the USA, your first intent with a mobile should be to purchase it completely, and then keep your option of carrier open. Does this mean that using Verizon, Sprint, and other CDMA-based carriers decline in option? It does? These mobiles might offer you the best signal here, but unless you are purchasing their global models (models that are locked for VZW/Sprint in the USA but have a GSM radio that is unlocked for outside the States), then yes you are stuck.

You’ve always had a choice though. And this call by CTIA is in part going to make you a smarter consumer of mobile devices. Whether it works best for you or not will take a bit more homework and recommendations.

  • Pingback: Unlocked Mobiles and Your Choice | Church Tech()

  • Nancy

    Thank you for noting additional unlocked mobile options as well as the limitations that other media didn’t fully disclose. I didn’t have to ask questions or assume answers. The second hand phone industry is being held at bay in the US while the big providers are gathering all of their available resources to quickly meet the world demands for mobile social media and on-demand TV .

  • Nancy

    Thank you for noting additional unlocked mobile options as well as the limitations that other media didn’t fully disclose. I didn’t have to ask questions or assume answers. The second hand phone industry is being held at bay in the US while the big providers are gathering all of their available resources to quickly meet the world demands for mobile social media and on-demand TV .